One Skirt, Fifth Season

I was never really happy with the concluding outfit for my One Skirt, Four Seasons series.

Was it the tucked-in shirt, looking bulgy and unkempt? Or the equal length of skirt and shirt, making me appear boxy? Or was it simply that I failed to garner enough votes on Chictopia? I'm not sure, but whatever the reason, I wanted to give this outfit another try.

This time, I untucked the shirt, resulting in both a sleeker silhouette and a variation in lengths.

I also upgraded my jewelry to a cute matched set.

And here's just one more look at those fabulous shoes.

Which way do you prefer this outfit? Tucked and teachery? Or untucked and Unfashionistic?